Christmas Ads: In with the new, or in with the old?

New ads grab the headlines, but the old favourites may be the smarter Christmas investment

Every year a wonderful array of Christmas ads lands on our screens, as rich as a plum pudding with stunning soundtracks, beautiful storytelling and famous faces to bring it all together. But are we spending our Christmas money in the right place?


The new arrivals

The latest ads turn up a few weeks ahead of schedule, like a first-time guest at the Christmas table, keen to make a good impression because we don’t know them all that well yet. These guests come bearing huge presents, or should I say huge production budgets, and often take up more airtime with an extended or cinematic version to showcase a big personality, both on screen and across our social feeds.


The Halloween decorations are barely down before the nation’s conversation turns to these new favourites, a tradition started by John Lewis in 2007. This year we were charmed by Niall, the Tesco shop assistant who might just be an elf, and across the water, Waitrose brought us the second episode of the unlikely couple, Keira Knightley and Phil, in a romcom packed with Love Actually and Notting Hill references.


The old favourites

But roll on another few weeks and our returning favourites make their grand entrance. These are the much-loved “old” ads we watched way back when we were the ones excited for Santa. They don’t come with all the bells and whistles of a new production. They are the Quality Street of TV ads and need only a light touch to draw on our Christmas emotions.


Every song, every chime, every doorbell that rings, the crunch of snow underfoot, evokes a Christmas memory of our own, and we welcome these ads with open arms. They tell us Christmas has truly arrived, like St. James’s Gate covered in snow with its familiar “Don’t forget to turn the lights off”.


Those little specks of brilliance pull on our heartstrings, and in no time we’re all singing along. Some newcomers have joined the party too and are already wearing in nicely. Woodie’s Mrs Higgins, launched in 2020, reminds us each Christmas that “We’re all homemakers”, and Amazon’s “Joy Ride”, with three lifelong friends grinning like schoolgirls as they sledge down a snowy hill, arrived in 2023. Both have the makings of future classics.


Gone too soon

Then there are the ads cut down before their time. They live on in faraway corners of the internet, occasionally surfacing for us to fall for them all over again. The ones I miss most are Lidl’s poignant “Homecoming” ad, with a grandad surrounded by family beside his late wife’s empty chair, and the now famous An Post “Walking in the Air” ad with that haunting voiceover.


Campaigns wear in, not out

The evidence tells us that campaigns don’t wear out, they wear in. System1 analysed more than 50,000 ads and found their effectiveness holds for years. Too often, we retire our ads because we’re bored of them, not because the public is. Even the new ads prove it, leaning on familiar touchpoints like music and well-known actors to earn the right to be remembered.


Why ads bow out early

So why do some ads bow out early? The reasons range from usage rights expiring to the size and resolution of our screens, to changing agencies and teams, and I’m guessing not everyone wants an ex sitting at the Christmas table. Most of these are practical. But there’s also our appetite for the new. Few brands can compete with the big Christmas TV budgets, but it’s worth remembering that wearing in over the years is an effective strategy in its own right. Invest in production in year one, then invest in broad reach every year after. Just make sure the research is done first, or you could end up with a different kind of turkey for Christmas.


Mixing the old and the new

Today there are more options to mix the old and the new. One is to keep the same master TV ad and extend it into other media. You save on production and bring something different in other formats. Coca-Cola do this brilliantly, taking “Holidays Are Coming” into outdoor and other media in interesting ways, carrying their distinctive assets with them: the trucks, the jingle and the colours.


The sound of Christmas

Not every Christmas classic needs a screen. The Barry’s Tea “Trainset” ad has been running on radio for over 30 years and is as lovely today as it ever was. It’s a perfect example of audio capturing the nostalgia of our childhood and giving the brand real warmth. And long before anyone was making cinematic cuts, it ran at a full 90 seconds. The story behind it is almost as good as the ad.


By Fiona Field, Published in Marketing.ie November 2026

Photo by Igor Lifar