AI and Copyright: We Can’t Afford to Fail Again
Notes from the Copyright & Human Creativity in the Age of AI conference, an Ireland EU Presidency event, held at the IFI, Dublin
“We should treat AI the way we treat food labelling. We need to know what we’re putting in our minds.” – Dr Conor Kostick, writer and historian, Irish Writers’ Union and European Writers’ Council.
That line stuck with me most from 20 pages of furiously scribbled notes (in a Google notebook, the irony!) at the conference Copyright & Human Creativity in the Age of AI, hosted by NewsBrands Ireland and IRMA on [DATE] as an associated event of Ireland’s EU Presidency.
What’s at stake
It was shocking to see the impact LLMs have already had on the media industry, and hard to stomach how much content has been used without permission as speaker after speaker illustrated the problem. Much of the discussion centred on what’s at stake if news media keeps shrinking. Michael McNamara MEP, Co-Chair, AI Act Implementation Working Group, hopes Europe avoids the media deserts we are seeing in the US.
Three themes: enforcement, transparency, consent
- Enforcement: “Without granularity, we can’t enforce.” – Wout van Wijk, Executive Director, News Media Europe
- Transparency: Michael McNamara called its absence the greatest impediment: “How can you agree a licence?”
- Consent: Ruadhán Mac Cormaic, Editor of The Irish Times, described content being “hoovered up” by AI companies that “didn’t ask for any permission.” Publishers and the industry simply want “a level playing field.”
Reasons for hope
But there was some hope too. In the morning, Enda Parker, Director of Business Development, AudioStack, showed a very effective use of AI: producing radio commercials with ethically sourced, licensed voices. Given our love of radio in this country, he explained how it can help keep ad budgets in local communities rather than losing them to social media.
After lunch, Karen Rønde, Director of Regulatory Relations EU & Big Tech, Amedia, told us how Danish media came together through DPCMO. After efforts to negotiate failed, they took OpenAI to court. She urged us all to speak with one voice.
The lesson from social media
Having worked in media for nearly 30 years, I know trust in news has always mattered. As Wout van Wijk noted, models trained on news perform better, but the money must flow back to the media.
Naoise Ó Cearúil TD, Chair, Oireachtas Committee on AI, was honest: “We completely failed with social media.” Personally, I think the harsh truth is that we now face the same problem, only bigger. Had social media been properly regulated years ago, publishers might not have given so much away for free in the chase for reach. More would sit behind paywalls, and there would have been much less to scrape. We can’t afford to fail again, because “countries that get ahead will stay ahead, and countries that get left behind will be left behind.”
Thanks to Annemarie Lenihan and Lisa Buckley of NewsBrands Ireland, David Kitching of IRMA and the European Commission for a really interesting day.
By Fiona Field, October 2026, LinkedIn
Image: Caleb Oquendo, Pexels
